Criminal Justice and Criminology by Marcia Canavan
Home
Home
Syllabus
Course Requirements
Assignment Schedule
Visit My Home Page
Email Dr. Nees

 

Crime and Justice in the US, Review of the Criminal Justice System

Weeks 12 and 13



Web Links for Review:

Backfire: When Incarceration Increases Crime

Bearing the Burden: How Incarceration Weakens Inner City Communities


Incarceration Rates by Race

Required Readings:

Permeation of Race, National Origin and Gender Issues from Initial Law Enforcement Contact through Sentencing: The Need for Sensitivity, Equalitarianism and Vigilance in the Criminal Justice System, Arthur L. Burnett, American Criminal Law Review Summer 1994 31 n4 p1153-1175 (search by the authors name)

DWB Driving While Black, Joy Bennett Kinnon, Ebony Sept 1999 v54 i11 p62

Metro State Home Page

How to Access These Articles

PDF Files for Review:

Minorities and the Juvenile Justice System

To read these files you will need the Adobe Acrobat Reader. If you do not have on your computer, download a free copy here.

Colorado (DOC and State Statistics):

Ethnicity

Race:
Colorado Population
Percent in Prison
Anglo
81%
44.0%
Hispanic
12.9%
26.7%
African American
3.9%
23.7%
Native American
.7%
1.9%
Asian American
1.7%
0.6%
Unknown/other
.1%
3.1%


Segment Requirements
Assignment
Learning Objectives:
  • Gain knowledge of the involvement of minorities in the juvenile justice system.

  • Develop an understanding of the implications of the issues.

  • Develop strategies to work towards solutions.
Review Topics:
  • What will the future impact of the nature of the current incarceration rates be for the United States.

  • What are the primary causes of minority overrepresentation in the criminal justice system?
Discussion Topics:
  1. Which, if any, laws lead to the greatest disparity in the incarceration rates among the different races?
Writing Requirement:
  • Which strategies have the greatest opportunity for successful change in the justice system?
Review Questions
  1. Describe racial profiling as used by police officers.


  2. Are African-Americans over represented in the justice system?

Text Answers

Click these icons to listen to audio answers.

Additional Information:

Disparity versus Discrimination:

Disparity: A difference, but not discrimination.

Discrimination: Differential treatment of groups without reference to an individual's behavior or qualifications.

Additional Definitions:

Systemic Discrimination: Discrimination at all stages of the criminal justice system at all times and all places.

Institutionalized Discrimination:

Racial and ethnic disparities in outcomes that are the result of the application of racially neutral facts such as prior criminal record, employment status, demeanor, etc.

Contextual Discrimination:

Discrimination found in particular contexts or circumstances (e.g., certain regions, particular crimes, special victim-offender relationships).

Individual Acts of Discrimination:

Discrimination that results from the acts of particular individuals but is not characteristic of entire agencies or the criminal justice system as a whole.

Some theorists have offered ideas why there are differences among the various races. They include:

Conflict Theory:

There is a conflict between the majority - whites and the minority groups.

Consensus Theory:

That crime is explained by individual acts of deviancy.

For additional information please review a basic sociology text, or an introduction to criminal justice systems text.

Top

E-Mail Dr. Nees

Web Page for Hal Nees